GoHotelly
4-star hotel Check-in 15:00 · Check-out 11:00

The Inn at Bay Fortune - Five Star Luxury Inn

Rustic-chic inn with bay views, upscale dining, and LGBTQ+ friendly service in Souris, PE. Near Souris Historic Lighthouse and Charlottetown Airport.

758 Route 310, Souris, PE C0A 2B0, Canada View on map
9.6/10
Exceptional Based on 585 recent guest reviews
Free Wi-Fi Free breakfast Free parking Accessible Air-conditioned
What recent guests emphasize

Exceptional Culinary Experience and Attentive Service

Guests consistently highlight the unique dining events, passionate staff, and immersive farm-to-table philosophy. The inn combines rustic charm with refined hospitality, making it a memorable destination for food lovers and those seeking a serene retreat.

Guests often praise

  • The extraordinary dining experiences, especially the Fireworks Feast and oyster hour, featuring fresh, locally sourced ingredients.
  • Attentive, friendly, and passionate staff who enhance the overall visit and create a welcoming atmosphere.
  • The unique connection to the land and sea, including informative farm tours and the philosophy behind sustainable food practices.
  • Beautiful, well-appointed rooms with some offering picturesque bay views.
  • Thoughtful personalized touches, such as special arrangements for celebrations and exclusive seating at the Chef’s table.

Worth knowing

  • The inn operates seasonally, so availability is limited to certain months.
  • Dining events are long experiences (e.g., 6+ hours) and require advance booking due to high demand.
  • The price point reflects the exceptional quality and full experience but may not suit budget travelers.
  • Its remote location requires a car, with the nearest highway about 8 km away and the harbor 28 km distant.
  • The inn prioritizes sustainability and local sourcing, appealing strongly to eco-conscious visitors but may feel niche to casual diners.

Best for

  • Food enthusiasts seeking an unforgettable farm-to-table culinary adventure.
  • Guests looking for a refined yet rustic inn with personal and attentive service.
  • LGBTQ+ travelers appreciating inclusive and welcoming accommodations.
  • Couples celebrating special occasions such as honeymoons or proposals.
  • Visitors wanting to explore serene natural surroundings, including nearby parks and historic sites.
Compare booking partners

Open this hotel on the platform you trust.

GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.

Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.

About this property

Welcome to The Inn at Bay Fortune - Five Star Luxury Inn

The Inn at Bay Fortune - Five Star Luxury Inn offers a rustic-chic lodging experience set in a refined inn originally built in 1913 as a summer home for a Broadway playwright. Located along 758 Route 310 in Souris, Prince Edward Island, the inn sits near Bay Fortune and is accessible by a 54-minute drive from Charlottetown Airport. The seasonal property provides guests with quiet surroundings approximately 8 km from Highway 2 and 28 km from the harbour in Souris.

Accommodations feature thoughtfully designed rooms, some of which boast views of the nearby bay. The property is known for its upscale restaurant focusing on a farm-to-table culinary philosophy, celebrated for its unique dining experiences such as the Fireworks Feast and attentive service. Reviews frequently mention the quality and artistry of the food, the passionate staff, and the integration of locally sourced ingredients and gardens, enhancing the seasonal menu offerings.

The inn welcomes a diverse crowd, including LGBTQ+ travelers, and is positioned well for visitors interested in exploring local attractions like the Souris Historic Lighthouse, Red Point Provincial Park, and Sally’s Beach Provincial Day Park, all within a short drive. Guests seeking a combination of relaxed countryside ambiance with exceptional dining will find the property appealing.

Check-in is at 15:00 with check-out by 11:00, and the property’s commitment to a genuine connection with the land and sea surfaces in both its hospitality and culinary approach. While the setting is peaceful and somewhat remote, nearby accommodations, ranging from inns to motels, provide additional options within a 5-6 mile radius.

Summary compiled by GoHotelly editors from verified guest reviews, partner descriptions and editorial notes.
Facilities & essentials

What's on-site and what you should know before you arrive

The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.

Most popular facilities

Free Wi-Fi
Free breakfast
Free parking
Accessible
Air-conditioned
Kid-friendly
Restaurant
Bar
Smoke-free

Not available at this property

Pool
Pet-friendly
Airport shuttle
Fitness center
Verified guest reviews

What recent guests are actually saying

Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.

DS
Don Strickland Apr 14, 2026
10

We enjoyed another exceptional dining experience at the Inn at Bay Fortune, during our visit to PEI again this year. The food and service are excellent, but it is really the full experience of the food stations outside in the garden, and connecting nature to the quality of the food, that makes it unique. This is a must for anyone that is passionate about quality food and taking care of the land and sea.

ARG
AKSHAY REDDY GUDIPATI Mar 15, 2026
10

I had an incredible dinner experience at The Inn at Bay Fortune yesterday! From start to finish, everything was exceptional. Our server Scott was absolutely the best — attentive, friendly, and made the evening feel extra special. The chefs were true professionals, and I really appreciated how Chef Daniel took the time to explain each dish, making the whole experience more personal and memorable. The food itself was outstanding — every plate was beautifully prepared, bursting with flavor, and the desserts were simply awesome. This was more than just dinner, it was an unforgettable dining experience. Highly recommend The Inn at Bay Fortune if you’re visiting PEI!

GM
Graeme Moss Mar 09, 2026
10

Attended the Fireworks feast. Exceptional experience. I am not a foodie but it was a great experience. I was impressed with the philosophy. Treatment of staff. Arrived at 3 pm to see fields where vegetables are grown. Given a real passionate explaination of cultivation. Lasted 6 hrs and 25 minutes but went by fast. Not rushed. An experience. The passion is infectious. Was paced perfectly. I enjoyed how motivated the staff were. There were about 70 guests. Totally unique dining experience. Worth the price. I am a bit of a food heathen lol but the presentation was quite artistic. Very memorable! Everyone was motivated but I found basic philosophy of Michael Smith to be a bonding agent.

TS
Trevor Schellenberg Feb 27, 2026
10

My only qualm is that the scale only goes to 5 stars. On top of this being part of our honeymoon, this was a bucket list event for both of us. I've followed Chef Michael since I was a young chef and my partner goes gaga over gardens. Everything from the check-in, to the rooms, to Oyster Hour, to the toasts and family style dinners (and the surprise breakfast we had no idea about) was incredible. I'm very rarely at a loss for words but I was in such bliss this entire time, that if ever I failed to express how happy we were being here, I am sorry. We can't wait to return, with friends in tow. Kash and Trevor

-T
- Tizz Feb 24, 2026
10

The Inn at Bay Fortune offers an unparalleled farm to table culinary experience in a relaxed and unpretentious environment. Celebrity Chef Michael Smith and his Fire Brigade carefully curate a daily menu that's centered on the peak taste and texture from the fields around the facility. With a on-staff professional forager, Instagram celebrity Nick of the North, provides exceptional local ingredients that are simply unavailable anywhere else. Be it a comfortable weekend away or a once-in-a-lifetime visit that's not soon to be forgotten I'd highly recommend investigating the Inn at Bay Fortune

MS
Mary Sheridan Feb 12, 2026
10

This is truly a foodie find. The Fireworks Feast was an incredible and absolutely unforgettable experience. The welcoming team, including the bar hands were amazing upon arrival and we loved our quaint, well appointed room. The farm chat with Kevin then Michael was informative and fun and gave us context on why this is a total passion place. The oyster hour with other apps was literally jaw dropping. Dinner was a well orchestrated ballet of sorts - mesmerizing in fact. The food was off the chains delish and portions were perfect. We are already looking at booking next year. Thanks to Chef Michael & team for invigorating my culinary keenness! I WILL be making the recipes from the cookbook. Thanks for signing it! We were so fortunate to enjoy Bay Fortune your way!!!!

KL
kenny l Jan 17, 2026
10

Transcendence is defined as a heightened sense of connection and awareness. A bit much? Nope! Coming to the The Inn at Bay Fortune for the Fireworks Feast is something beyond a meal, and it surpasses an experience. Transcendence. My favorite part was the oyster hour, with 5 serving stations, raw oysters (3 varieties), grilled oysters, roasted duck hearts, smoked salmon, grilled bluefin tuna and Taco's! Patrick and I became fast friends at the oyster bar. He shucked, I ate! Matt's farmer talk was great, he is so passionate about the Inn, and gave a terric talk about the farm and inn. The main feast was incredible, with every dish prepared perfectly. I had nothing to critique about anything. People come from around the world to elevate their culinary journey, as should you. Book way in advance, and prepare to be amazed. I sure was. P.s. their oyster shucking record will be broken this year of over 66,000. In 166 days, that's a lot of oysters. I ate over 2 dozen. I did my part, now you do yours!

MM
Matt McCluskey Jan 11, 2026
10

Absolutely amazing time staying at the Inn with my fiancée. I reached out to reception prior to arriving, to let them know that i would be proposing and asked if they had any recommendations. The staff went above and beyond to make the day extra special for us, including an arrangement in our room and seating at the Chef's table - which we did not expect! The farm and inn were beautifully maintained and clearly a lot of thought went into the design. The service is unmatched - every staff member is happy to be there and expresses passion in their work. Last but not least - the food was exceptional. It wasn't just a stay at an inn and a nice dinner, it was an entire experience that we will never forget. We will be back again.

Location & neighborhood

Where you'll find The Inn at Bay Fortune - Five Star Luxury Inn

Souris, Prince Edward Island, Canada

Dating to 1913 and originally a summer home for a Broadway playwright, this refined inn (open seasonally) is next to Bay Fortune, 8 km from Highway 2 and 28 km from the harbour in Souris.

  • Charlottetown Airport 54 min Car
Things to do nearby

Worth the walk or a quick ride

Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in Prince Edward Island. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.

Red Point Provincial Park 294 reviews

Red Point Provincial Park

249 Red Point Park Rd, Elmira, PE C0A 2B0, Canada

4.6 · Park
Souris Historic Lighthouse 248 reviews

Souris Historic Lighthouse

134 Breakwater St, Souris, PE C0A 2B0, Canada

4.6 · Tourist Attraction
Sally's Beach Provincial Day Park 67 reviews

Sally's Beach Provincial Day Park

736 Spry Point Rd, Souris, PE C0A 2B0, Canada

4.5 · Beach
People also viewed

Similar Inns in Prince Edward Island

Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.

352 Rue Félix Antoine Savard, Saint-Joseph-de-la-Rive, QC G0A 3Y0, Canada

Auberge la Maison Sous les Pins

Enjoy airconditioned, kidfriendly rooms and a seasonal terrace restaurant at Auberge la Maison Sous les Pins, just minutes from ...

4.5 (39) View
1200 Caribou Rd, Bracebridge, ON P1L 1X1, Canada

Caribou Lodge

Enjoy free WiFi and parking at Caribou Lodge, a 4.6rated resort hotel in Bracebridge, ON. Close to Wood Lake, Bracebridge Falls,...

4.6 (65) View
405 Spray Ave, Banff, AB T1L 1J4, Canada

Fairmont Banff Springs

Stay at Fairmont Banff Springs, a 4.7star resort hotel in Banff with golf, spa, refined restaurants, indoor/outdoor pools, and pr...

4.7 (16,391) View
20 Strachan Ct SE, Medicine Hat, AB T1B 4R7, Canada

Home Inn Express Medicine Hat

4.5star budget hotel in Medicine Hat offering free parking, breakfast, WiFi, and LGBTQ+ friendly amenities. Close to Saamis Tepe...

4.5 (591) View
4316 48 Ave, Castor, AB T0C 0X0, Canada

Grey Goose Motel

Stay at Grey Goose Motel, a 3.6rated motel in Castor, AB. Enjoy free WiFi, parking, and kidfriendly amenities near Castor & Dis...

3.6 (81) View
4708 Highway Ave, Swan Hills, AB T0G 2C0, Canada

Grizzly Motel

Stay at Grizzly Motel, a 4.4star LGBTQ+ friendly motel in Swan Hills, AB. Enjoy proximity to Marigold Lake and easy access from E...

4.4 (56) View
1061 Manitoba Ave, Selkirk, MB R1A 3T7, Canada

Canalta Hotel Selkirk

Enjoy free breakfast, WiFi, and indoor pool at Canalta Hotel Selkirk, MB. Near Lower Fort Garry, Birds Hill Park, and 45 min from...

4.5 (691) View
3355 Buckhorn Rd, Buckhorn, ON K0L 1J0, Canada

Three Castles Resort

Rustic resort on Buckhorn Lake with free canoes, petfriendly airconditioned cabins, and easy access to Kawartha Lakes and nearby...

4.8 (119) View
53 Chem. Fiddleridge Resort, Mille-Isles, QC J0R 1A0, Canada

Chalet Blue Jay (#56) - par Chalets Zenya®

Enjoy a 5star stay at Chalet Blue Jay (#56) in MilleIsles, QC. Features free WiFi, outdoor pool, spa, petfriendly rooms, and e...

5 (48) View
Share your stay

Stayed at The Inn at Bay Fortune - Five Star Luxury Inn? Help the next traveler decide.

Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.

Your email is only used to verify the review — it won't be shown publicly.